As you might’ve read, an organization conducted a survey about Evangelical Christians and torture. The results? Most of them support torture. It honestly didn’t surprise me much. I found out about this on a blog on ChristianityToday. Surprisingly, it did not justify the support of torture, but actually argued against it with some very good points. It as well as some of the more insightful comments really convinced me that torture and Christianity cannot coexist.
The greatest point made was that the first question we should ask when it comes to torture is whether or not it is ethical. If it isn’t, then it is irrelevant if it works or not. After all, Christians condemn many atrocious practices based on the ethics alone: abortion, embryonic stem cell research, euthanasia, etc. Why should torture be any different? For the good of the nation? If the good of the nation requires us to sin against God, then to hell with the nation! Better to hate America and to love God than vice versa. The Israelites thought they were doing what was best for Israel when they sacrificed to Baal, but that didn’t appease God any nor did it absolve them of any sin.
How do we know if torture is ethical? One way is to ask ourselves if we would want it done to ourselves if in the same situation, whether we were found guilty of terrorism or simply thought to be terrorist by our nationality. It’s not surprising that the majority of people –some of whom I am sure support torture– would not want themselves or their children to be tortured themselves or their children to be tortured if they were found to be terrorists or suspected enemies of a nation they happened to be visiting. I doubt most people would want to be imprisoned without being officially charged with something either. They might even consider the act inhumane. It’s clear they consider it unethical when done to themselves, so why would they support it when done to others? Simply because their hypocrites. Is hypocrisy one of our spiritual gifts?
I wonder how many of them support the actions of the Spanish Inquisition of centuries before. They too tortured people for a greater good. In fact, one might argue that their goal was even more nobler than the goal we had with Guatanamo Bay: while the United States sought to save lives through torture, the Spanish Inquisition sought to save souls.
The second question to ask is not if it is effective, but if it is legal. This is much less ambiguous and debatable than the first question: it isn’t. Not according to the United States and not according to many official documents it has signed: The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, The Geneva Conventions, etc. (Here’s a quick overview of the many laws that torture violates). Are we as Christians expected to follow the law? Of course! Even if there are laws with which we don’t agree, God expects us to follow them! Even Jesus said “Give unto Caesar what is Caesar’s” and I’m sure that the Jews didn’t much care for the Romans. God won’t honor us if we act like criminals. The only time we may break the law is when the law of the land requires us to sin against God. Are there any verses that state it is a sin not to torture our enemies? Maybe in one of the supposed lost gospels! However, not in the Bible. Therefore, by intentionally violating the law, we are sinning against God and making a fool of Christ. You might not agree with federal law or the United Nations, but federal law was begotten by the United States government itself and the United States voluntarily sacrificed a bit of its sovereignty when it joined the United Nations and when it signed those many treaties against torture. If we don’t like the law of the land, then we should change it. If we don’t like the United Nations or the treaties we sign, then we should abandon them and suffer the consequences. Until then, we have an obligation to be obedient. If we can ignore the government whenever convenient, then why should we be obedient to any authority, whether in government or church or work, except when it profits us?
Now, one could ask if torture is effective. Those who support it deem it essential and those who oppose it claim it’s ineffective. Personally, I don’t care either way because it’s already clear that torture is unethical and illegal and therefore contradicts my walk with Christ. Does the security of the nation precede our walk with Christ? Only if you love the United States of America more than you love God. Yet, as one commenter eloquently stated: “American Christians are American first, Christian second.” I don’t disagree at all. The idolatry of America by supposed Christians is quite evident. There have been efforts made to amend the Constitution to ban the burning of the American flag. How many efforts have been made to amend the Constitution to ban the burning of Bibles? The Bible represents something far more sacred than the flag ever will. I wouldn’t be surprised if most American Christians disagreed with me though. Last time I checked the Bible though, we could only serve one master. So, who do you love more? God or America?